Posted on October 15, 2007,

Gaming Today Reviews Project Gotham Racing 4

review-pgr4-car1-screenshot.jpg

Heading into Project Gotham Racing 4, I expected a pretty standard fare; the established PGR formula of grinding away at each race, trying to get as many Kudos out of them as possible, only with motorcycles and various weather effects laid on top. While that is the reality of the matter, the game makes up for what appears to be an expansion pack on paper with pure thrills and a solid racing experience.

I’m feeling a tad queasy as I write this review, which doesn’t seem to be all that uncommon among gamers who have played with the bikes in PGR4. A new camera effect, which basically tilts the camera the opposite way you’re turning – almost to simulate the feeling of inertia when you’re driving – is something I noticed while racing with cars. I didn’t think much of it, other than it being a nice little effect to immerse you in the game. After an hour or two of racing cars, I took a bike for a spin and then I noticed how exacerbated the camera effect is – to the point where I was flat-out nauseous after driving for less than a minute. While I did adjust after 20 minutes or so, I noticed that I felt dizzy after walking away from my TV. So, just keep this as a buyer’s beware from someone who has never gotten motion sickness from a game before (including that Marathon: Durandal Xbox Live Arcade mess).

Despite the nausea factor, I found bikes fairly easy to drive right off the bat. While you do have to take on a different mentality from when you’re driving a car (breaking early and avoiding contact with other vehicles is obviously crucial), it doesn’t take long to get the hang of pulling off wheelies and overtaking other cars while on bikeback. (Is that a word? Should be.) The game also lacks the frustration factor that many other games featuring bikes has, where you feel like you have to slow to a crawl to make turns without landing on the pavement.

review-pgr4-bike-screenshot.jpg

Cars are equally as slick to drive. Bizarre has really refined the driving mechanics to where each car has an extremely distinct feel to it. Plenty of racing games can claim that, but PGR4 is about as good as you’re going to get in this regard outside of Forza Motorsport.

The straightforward and easily-accessible Arcade mode is intact, while the Gotham Career mode is a change in pace from previous PGR games. Unlike before, where you would select a race and repeat it as many times as you wished, PGR4 has you competing in seasons where various events come along and allow you to play them only once. Fail or succeed, you’ll have to wait until the following season to try again. While it’ll depend heavily on your preference, this struck me as a good thing. In PGR3, I felt like I needed to retry the same event over and over until I mastered it and got the maximum amount of Kudos out of it. PRG4, on the other hand, ushers you forward and keeps mixing things up with the different types of events (standard races, overtakes, time attacks, cone races, etc.) and different locations.

One particular instance of deviating from the norm was where you need to take an old 1950s hot dog-looking car around a snow-covered Nurburgring. It’s insanely challenging, as it’s easy to lose any and all traction (protip: don’t be afraid to let off the accelerator completely to regain your control) of your hot dog. And while I failed by a small margin, I couldn’t help but grin afterwards about how awesome that nine minutes was and think, “Next season, that’s mine.” It’s these unique challenges scattered throughout the career mode that make it particularly fun and worthwhile to continue along.

review-pgr4-hotdog-screenshot.jpg

Everything looks fantastic, especially when you take the time to stop a race and enter photo mode. (It’s lame that you need to do that to really experience what the game’s visuals have to offer, but boy, do they ever look good.) The new weather effects, like rain and snow, all look terrific and make enough of an impact on the racing itself that a sunny day on Nurburgring and a snowstorm on it are drastically different affairs.

Even though Forza 2 was released what only seems like a few months ago (actually, it was, come to think of it), PGR4 offers enough variation that diehard racing game fans will be happy to eat it up. For those of you out there who were put-off by Forza 2 and its seemingly insane amount of customization, PGR4 will still offer a solid racing experience while reducing the need to be a car junkie. Anyone can pick up and play the game, and while it does fall into a bit of a gray area between the Forza and Gran Turismos of the world and the Burnouts, the combination of bikes, fun challenges, gorgeous graphics and sweet weather effects make PGR4 worth picking up for any racing fan who hasn’t tired of the core PGR gameplay.

review-pgr4-car-screenshot.jpg

Presentation: 9 A slick interface and easy access to all of the game’s features – including a simple and easy way to paint cars however you’d like – make PGR4’s presentation first-rate.

Graphics: 9 These are definitely the best looking graphics we’ve seen in a racing game yet, and most likely will be until we see Gran Turismo 5 show up on PlayStation 3.

Sound: 7.5 A nice mixture of techno beats, albeit ones with strange lyrics to go along with them, and engine sounds make PGR4 nice to listen to.

Gameplay: 8.5 The PGR racing experience has been refined greatly, and offers very accessible simulation racing to those who don’t know how to properly align their car’s Johnson Rod.

Replay Value: 8.5 A lot of variety among race types, different weather effects that drastically change any given race, good online features, and challenging-but-achievable achievements.

Overall: 8.5 While PGR’s core gameplay remains unchanged overall, the various small tweaks and inclusion of a great new career mode and Kudos that work as currency make PGR4 the best PGR yet.

Geometry Wars: Waves: 8 I know you were all waiting for this part of the review. It’s an interesting take on Geometry Wars and is really quite fun despite its simplicity. But it ain’t worth paying $60 for, so you’ll just have to do without it if you’re not interested in PGR4.

Join the Conversation   

* required field

By submitting a comment here you grant GameFront a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Inappropriate or irrelevant comments will be removed at an admin's discretion.

3 Comments on Gaming Today Reviews Project Gotham Racing 4

Norbit

On October 15, 2007 at 1:37 pm

“Plenty of racing games can claim that, but PGR4 is about as good as you’re going to get in this regard outside of Forza Motorsport.”

Or any Gran Turismo game because they far more accurately replicate the real life car than Forza does.

I have to say this game appeals quite a lot to me and I would consider getting a 360 IF it had free online play.

Joelteon7

On October 15, 2007 at 2:29 pm

Because GT4′s every-car-feels-the-same approach (okay, not every, but pretty much all in every class which is 5, if my memory serves me obediantly) was really ‘realistic’. As simulator’s go, GT will be hard to be beaten. Fact. Fact is though, GT can get boring awefully quickly, especially when you unlock the F1 car when everything becomes boringly winnable.

As it goes, the 50′s mode looks pretty swell, so that gets my attention. I’ve been wanting to play a good fun racer for a bit (was thinking of picking up DiRT, but buying a 360 and already games for it on sale still left me with approxiamately zero money, s no DiRT) and it’s still some time till Mario Kart comes out…providing it ain’t too expensive, I may get it.

Though, I do wish there was another Wipeout for the PS2, or that that game went multi-platform. Best race, second to none in my opinion. Can’t beat a speed that goes into 4 digits and weapons that flip the track upside-down.

Xboxlenny

On October 16, 2007 at 9:28 am

PGR4 is awesome fun, like the article states, pick up and play, i enjoyed the demo, The bikes are also fun to race. Again another solid title from the Bizzarre team for the 360.

Forza Motor sport 2, thats true physics and realistic driving for the hard core racing fans, Some people dont like the realizm in driving you have to master. I would say this will give any Gran Turismo a run for its money. I bet Gran turismo 5 will be as good or even better. But Forza 2 is Hardcore racing at its best, PGR4 is great fun and the bikes and inside car view i enjoy