Heroes of the Storm: Blizzard Moves MOBAs Past ‘Dota Clones’

“So, does it feel more like DotA 2 or League of Legends?” my MOBA-inclined friends will ask me of Blizzard’s Heroes of the Storm.

“Neither,” I find myself replying, “It feels more like … Team Fortress 2.”

Let me explain. Defense of the Ancients 2 and LoL place a fairly equal emphasis on two distinct aspects of MOBA skill: individual micromanagement (lasthitting, denying, efficient farming) and teamwork (working together as a team to take objectives and win “team fights”). In Heroes of the Storm, the balance is skewed much more in favor of the teamwork skills, meaning it plays out more like a game of Team Fortress 2; while a single, skilled player can make a difference, he can’t exactly turn the tides of the battle by himself, and there’s much more opportunity for a losing team to come back from assured defeat.

Lost? Check out our extensive MOBA guide if you’re new to the genre.

Blizzard, rather than making another game that was simply derivative of the original DotA, has tried its best to shake the genre up a bit. If you asked most DotA 2 or LoL players and spectators what the most interesting part of the game was, few would say “the laning phase” (the period at the start of the game where everyone goes to their lanes to farm gold and experience), and most would probably tell you it was the epic end-game team fights. So Blizzard decided to just base its entire game around that.

While HotS games do actually start with a laning phase, it is often measurable in seconds, as it’s not long before players are running all over the map to try and take out enemy heroes and capture objectives. The reason why “level 1″ team fights in other MOBAs, those player-vs.-player battles that take place early in the game, are usually so dull is because champions only have one level of a single ability. HotS gives everyone access to three out of their four abilities right off the bat, meaning there’s a lot more incentive to get into a fight, rather than wait to become stronger.

Blizzard also makes three major changes in HotS that set it apart from the traditional MOBA.

Shaking up the formula

In HotS, there is no gold. There are no items. There is no pool of individual experience points. Each team has “team experience,” meaning that all players on a team level up at the same time, and you don’t have to worry about “farming” experience or falling behind your teammates (as is often the case for those poor support classes in other MOBAs).

Character customization is based around a set of “talents,” or upgrades and abilities, that you can choose every few levels. While on paper they don’t seem too impactful, over the course of the game they start to make a difference in tailoring your champion to a specific play style. I actually find the talent choices a lot more meaningful than item choice in LoL or DotA 2, because each of the talents available are equally viable choices. For example, one tier of Jim Raynor’s talents has a choice between increased range, increased damage, receiving life when he connects a successful hit, or reduced cooldowns. Do you want your Raynor to be a little more tanky? Or maybe you need him to deal more raw damage?

The other major customization option is that players can choose between two “ultimate” abilities at level 10. To again use Raynor as an example, his two ultimates allow him to call on Terran space ships from Starcraft 2: the battlecruiser Hyperion and Banshees. The Hyperion does large area-of-effect damage, while the Banshees will focus on the same target Raynor is attacking — again letting players choose if they want to be an AOE powerhouse or a ranged assassin.

Pretty much every hero has an interesting, viable choice between his or her two ultimates — I never came across a situation where I felt like one ultimate was “better” than the other.

In LoL and DotA 2, on the other hand, apart from a handful of minor variations, there is pretty much a best build for every single champion and situation, meaning that the “choice” of how you upgrade your character with items is pretty much an illusion. Blizzard has applied the valuable “less is more” lesson it learned with its World of Warcraft talent system to HotS: Having fewer choices that actually make a difference is much better than having a lot of choices with only one or two viable paths.

Another interesting twist in Heroes of the Storm: Dying isn’t a big deal. No gold, no items, and the fact that you still earn experience when you are dead mean the only real penalty to dying is that … well, you’re dead. You can’t help out your team while you’re dead, but that’s it. This led me to a greater number of cool “blaze of glory” moments when I played, in which I was more willing to try and take out a key player or stop an enemy from gaining a key objective, without fearing my death and granting the enemy team a whole bunch of gold (and having my team yell at me).

This also allows the meta of the game to shift from entire teams trying to “gank” a random hero to frequent, frantic team fights based around the map’s various powerful objectives. These changes also allow Heroes of the Storm to successfully pull off what so many other MOBAs have tried (and failed) to do — multiple maps.

Join the Conversation   

* required field

By submitting a comment here you grant GameFront a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Inappropriate or irrelevant comments will be removed at an admin's discretion.

4 Comments on Heroes of the Storm: Blizzard Moves MOBAs Past ‘Dota Clones’

mt

On June 20, 2014 at 11:45 am

You’re dismissing Dota2 outright as very similar to Lol though. For instance, the choice for itemization in Dota2 is not an ‘illusion’ as you pointed it out. Having complete magic immunity for a few seconds is miles different with powerful damage items and yet you are not forced to pick it up on a single hero in every match up. Nor does the skill builds stay static. Sure there are for some but there will be others who would have multiple viable ways of building. On the other hand, nearly all heroes in Heroes of the Storm has a blink ability for a talent which plagues Lol until now. To its Blizzard’s credit, the other talents provide equal or even better options so you wouldn’t see such an ability be picked up as much.

Supports in dota2 aren’t the same in Lol either, nor do they need as much farm as the carries which means they do not suffer when not as farmed because they were built to stay effective with just their spells, something you described HoTs does. But the way you described them seems to me, that you think they’re similar to Lol which isn’t true. Supports in Dota2 are as fun to play and not ‘weak’ as you put it even if they don’t farm at all and just level.

Like you said, MOBA is a young genre. Everyone should realize that comparing different Mobas at this point requires putting them in context as there isn’t a written rule yet what a ‘moba’ should be like. For instance, I shouldn’t compare how freeing it is to have all heroes unlocked at all times in Dota2, which makes paying 4-10 dollars per hero for Heroes of the Storm debilitating. That would be comparing apples and oranges. You could argue that unlocking them has its own reasons, etc……but it shouldn’t mean one is better than the other.

derek

On June 20, 2014 at 5:27 pm

I find it disturbing that a company as experienced as blizzard would make the mistake of designing this game to use click-to-move controls. After basically changing the face of PvP gaming forever with WoW battlegrounds release in 2005 then further taking design elements from games like guild wars and fury, you’d think they would have released that WASD movement is perfect for any online battle arena game.

I guess the HotS developers never had the chance to play Smite.

Sean

On June 21, 2014 at 12:34 am

They are adding the option to change keybinds. Its still in alpha. l2google, jeezus

Drizzt

On June 23, 2014 at 10:15 am

Just a (minor) note: please don’t use “HotS” (especially in THAT capitalisation) for Heroes from Blizzard. On a cursory reading, ie. before reading it’s about the MOBA, it might be confused with Heart of the Swarm, which has been going by the abbreviation HotS for a lot longer. I’d suggest using just “Heroes” which is almost as short and clear.