The Wolf Among Us Episode 1 Review: Grimmly Satisfying

Trying to describe Fables, the long running DC Comics/Vertigo series written and created by Bill Willingham, risks making it sound like the most terminally silly concept ever attempted.

The premise: characters from fables, folklore and fairy tales are real, and hide in plain sight in a magically concealed community called Fabletown that sits in the middle of Manhattan. Driven to our world centuries ago by a ruthless enemy known only as “the adversary”, the fables attempt to maintain a low profile and dream of the day they might be able to mount an attack and retake their homelands. Lots of intrigue, murder, sex and the general range of human (or magical) awfulness ensues. The main characters include Prince Charming, The Big Bad Wolf, and Snow White. Yeah, it’s that kind of thing.

But the silly-sounding premise disguises the fact that Fables is one of the smartest comic series ever produced by the mainstream comics industry, which makes it a great fit for Telltale Games. Telltale, who previously took the idiotic zombie comic The Walking Dead and turned it into a thoughtful, character-driven story, works similar magic with The Wolf Among Us, a 5-part adaptation of Fables that captures the spirit and tone of the comic, and adds new wrinkles to the already complex story. The first episode is now available, and though it might be a tad esoteric for people who haven’t spent the last decade obsessing over the comic series, it’s a fun, engaging detective story with enough twists to keep Hammett fans and Grimm fans alike satisfied.

The Wolf Among Us: Episode 1
Platform: Xbox 360 (Reviewed), PS3, PC
Developer: Telltale Games
Publisher: Telltale Games
Released: October 11, 2013
MSRP: $4.99

The strength of Fables is that, much like Neil Gaiman’s The Sandman, it’s a story as much about stories themselves as about the characters in it. Series-creator Bill Willingham is a vast repository of literary and folklore knowledge and he puts it to good use, using the original stories as a jumping-off point for exploring class struggles, real world political hot potatoes, and sometimes just the chance to show off. While his reimagined characters often bear little resemblance to their original-story counterparts, they’re always tied to the stories from which they came, making it easy to jump between spy thrillers, epic war stories, romantic drama, even detective fiction, which is where The Wolf Among Us starts.

Set about 10 years before Fables’ 2003 debut, Bigby Wolf – AKA the Big Bad Wolf of Red Riding Hood and the Three Little Pigs – serves as Sheriff of Fabletown. Tasked with investigating any and all crimes related to Fablekind, he must also enforce laws that keep their existence a secret from the mundane world. After a routine visit to a tenement in The Bronx to check out a domestic violence complaint involving two very different fables, he finds himself caught up in the murder of an obscure Fable woman called Donkeyskin.

Over the course of investigating the crime – joined by assistant Deputy Mayor of Fabletown Snow White – he begins to catch glimpses of a larger conspiracy within the Fable community. Of course, things don’t go smoothly: centuries-old grudges and serious financial pressure lead more than one character to deceive or even attack Bigby, and the episode culminates in a shocking cliffhanger, at least for people who’ve never read the comic series.

One thing the game gets particularly right is the tenuous relationship between the various characters. In the comic’s backstory, upon arriving in the mundane world many centuries earlier, the fables agreed for the sake of unity and cohesion to forgive past wrongdoings by any Fable who sought refuge in Fabletown. This means any wrongdoing, including the countless magical animals and people Bigby ate murdered during his tenure as Big Bad Wolf. While the citizens of Fabletown adhere to the letter of the law, it’s obvious many of them haven’t forgiven in their hearts. This causes plenty of problems for Bigby as he questions former enemies connected to the case, and it’s nice the way the game nails Bigby’s outsider status while never sugar-coating the reasons for it.

The game’s story also hints at the class struggle bubbling under the Fable community. Wealthy (or connected) fables get to live in a luxury hi-rise, with access to magic that conceals their nature and allows them to more or less move about the mundane world without trouble. Poor fables are stuck living in the projects, barely keeping it together and sinking into the abyss as poverty does it’s usual trick of ruining relationships as well as one’s hopes and dreams.

Join the Conversation   

* required field

By submitting a comment here you grant GameFront a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Inappropriate or irrelevant comments will be removed at an admin's discretion.

4 Comments on The Wolf Among Us Episode 1 Review: Grimmly Satisfying


On October 18, 2013 at 9:39 pm

So this piece of unfinished crap gets an 89 while beyond 2 souls gets a 55. I give up. Telltale makes a bunch of crappy games. Is it because its 5 bucks? THIS IS NOT A COMPLETE GAME. Ugh…


On October 19, 2013 at 3:47 am

Michael, are you trying to win some award for the most vapid comments ever posted? I know from your troll posts on the Beyond: Two Souls review (which was completely fair and accurate) that you’ve got your tongue lodged up David Cage’s rectum and can’t accept when valid criticism is directed towards his work, but this is just too stupid to even really analyse. The Wolf Among Us is not ‘unfinished’ – it’s episodic. The episode itself IS finished. The whole idea of an episode videogame is that it’s released in self-contained episodes. If you can’t understand that basic concept then you should just give up on videogames entirely. The irony is that David Cage’s games have such piss-poor writing that they come closer to being unfinished than just about anything.

Please do give up, because what you’re trying to achieve is on par with a lobotomised dung beetle.


On March 26, 2015 at 2:23 am

Hi!I’m Janine and I’m a member of EVOKE, an olnnie game that allows us to find ideas on how to make this world a better place. This week’s task was to find a social innovation role model and I chose you, Nitin Das!Thank you for making a difference!

auto insurance

On April 9, 2015 at 12:44 pm

I discovered your blog yesterday and started follow your posts regularly. I have not commented on any blog just yet but I was contemplating I would like to. It’s very exciting to actually contribute to a publication even if it’s only a blog. I really don’t know exactly what to say other than I actually enjoyed reading through 6 of the posts. Nice articles indeed. I sure will keep visiting your blog daily. I learned quite a bit from you. Thx!