I didn't make it!
Other: The legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
Scariest game ever made, hands down.
Beats all others by a long shot.
I would have to say Alien vs Predator 2. When i would play it, i would always have the shoulder light on for the marine, but when it ran out, i would sit there, in the dark...and there just hearing the beeping of my rader knowing that an alien was near. Except for the fact that every single time an alien would come out at u they played that same exact song or w/e time after time. Doom 3 scared me at first, but then got repetitve. Best part in doom 3, when that chick's head blows off. heh,
I've always been paranoid when playing "scary games." Whenever something would happen I'd jump. Of course... I've gotten better at it over the years.. but.. meh. Actually when I was playing the FEAR demo, right when you hear static on your radio for the first time, my brother jumped right behind me and shook my chair, scared the crap out of me. My theory is that it's the ambient music in the game that would scare people the most.
yes, in almost any game it seems when i hear the ominous music or something i know somethin bad is going to happen, so i start gettin tense, and then if something sudden does happen, good or bad, it surprises me
Fatal Frame is the scariest game ever! The premise sounds stupid.. you have a magic camera and you shoot the ghosts with this camera.. BUT the game is actually very good and it is 10x's scarier than fear. Not to say Fear wasn't scarey .. because it is.
i didnt think FEAR was scary at all maybe in some parts i jumped and thought it was pretty screwed up but i find silent hill 1 and 2 were scary! pyramid head:( now that was scary...silent hill 3 and 4 were stupid (bad job on the monsters)