Who would win in a battle between Revan and Luke? -1 reply

Please wait...

Deus Oblivionis

Domini de Umbra

50 XP

12th August 2008

0 Uploads

871 Posts

0 Threads

#1 10 years ago

Okay for my first thread I'm gonna dare ask the question of who would win between Revan and Luke. In my opinion, it would be one hell of a fight but Luke would win. Obi-Wan even said that Luke was the most powerful Jedi that he'd had the pleasure of teaching and before Obi left, told Luke that it was his destiny to bring back the Jedi Order. If that doesn't scream "LUKE WILL WIN" then i don't know what does. (FYI I'm a huge Revan fan I'm just stating my opinion)


Alucardsig2-1.jpg



Penguin_Unit

Uh-oh.

50 XP

8th May 2007

0 Uploads

6,077 Posts

0 Threads

#2 10 years ago

They would be evenly matched. Depends on which alignment Revan, though. Light or Dark? Either way, though, methinks Luke > Revan. If I see one more fanboy vote Revan just because of he's "cool"...




Razgriz1928

Strength Through Progress

50 XP

26th October 2007

0 Uploads

1,694 Posts

0 Threads

#3 10 years ago

Luke because he had one of the most highest midi-chlorian counts of all time and was a swordsmaster (not that revan wasn't)




Jedijax

I follow teh Moo!

50 XP

9th October 2007

0 Uploads

575 Posts

0 Threads

#4 10 years ago

Definitely Skywalker, and not because he is Anakin's little boy, or because he's the Star Wars Saga's iconic hero. You've gotta look at the facts: Luke is the Grand Master of the New Jedi Order, a guy who has trained practicaly every single knight since the Jedi Purge in one way or another; some of his students are outstanding duelists, and still they can't beat him. He defeated Kam Solusar in Nespis, the Force-user who later became the official Swordmaster of the NJO. He also taught Kyle Katarn, the second Swordmaster of the NJO. And to add to this, Kyp Durron, Leia, Anakin, Jacen and Jaina Solo were his students and are exceptional lightsaber fighters. However, this by itself would not sway me if I were you, the single fact that makes you see Luke is one of the greatest duelists out there, is he was able to defeat Palpatine, with all his experience and skill developed over almost a century, and in a young, powerful body!! Man, a Jedi doesn't get any better than that!! :bows: Also, It has been repeatedly suggested in the books Luke mastered each and every form of lightsaber combat, as he has used them progressively since The Truce at Bakura to defeat lots of Dark Jedi and Sith; the guy even gave Shimra a run for his money, and we are talking about the best warrior of a race exceptional at killing Jedi!! Now, let's look at Revan's facts. For all the fame the guy has, there is not an official record of his dueling skills. Everybody goes around saying he was a great lightsaber fighter, but the truth is we may only objectively say he MUST have been an exceptional fighter, as a deduction borne out of his role in the KOTOR storyline. Since most of the Revanchist's achievements do not spring from duel, or are up to gameplayer's skill, rather than actual storytelling, his ability in this particular cannot be measured accurately. But even then, just do the math of how many times he fought, how many enemies fell by his blade, and then compare it to Skywalker's kill-number... you will see there is not even a comparison. Revan is a powerful figure of HIS time, but Luke is a powerful figure of ALL times. :nodding: And that, my friends, is a fact.




Deus Oblivionis

Domini de Umbra

50 XP

12th August 2008

0 Uploads

871 Posts

0 Threads

#5 10 years ago
Jedijax;4503823Definitely Skywalker, and not because he is Anakin's little boy, or because he's the Star Wars Saga's iconic hero. You've gotta look at the facts: Luke is the Grand Master of the New Jedi Order, a guy who has trained practicaly every single knight since the Jedi Purge in one way or another; some of his students are outstanding duelists, and still they can't beat him. He defeated Kam Solusar in Nespis, the Force-user who later became the official Swordmaster of the NJO. He also taught Kyle Katarn, the second Swordmaster of the NJO. And to add to this, Kyp Durron, Leia, Anakin, Jacen and Jaina Solo were his students and are exceptional lightsaber fighters. However, this by itself would not sway me if I were you, the single fact that makes you see Luke is one of the greatest duelists out there, is he was able to defeat Palpatine, with all his experience and skill developed over almost a century, and in a young, powerful body!! Man, a Jedi doesn't get any better than that!! :bows: Also, It has been repeatedly suggested in the books Luke mastered each and every form of lightsaber combat, as he has used them progressively since The Truce at Bakura to defeat lots of Dark Jedi and Sith; the guy even gave Shimra a run for his money, and we are talking about the best warrior of a race exceptional at killing Jedi!! Now, let's look at Revan's facts. For all the fame the guy has, there is not an official record of his dueling skills. Everybody goes around saying he was a great lightsaber fighter, but the truth is we may only objectively say he MUST have been an exceptional fighter, as a deduction borne out of his role in the KOTOR storyline. Since most of the Revanchist's achievements do not spring from duel, or are up to gameplayer's skill, rather than actual storytelling, his ability in this particular cannot be measured accurately. But even then, just do the math of how many times he fought, how many enemies fell by his blade, and then compare it to Skywalker's kill-number... you will see there is not even a comparison. Revan is a powerful figure of HIS time, but Luke is a powerful figure of ALL times. :nodding: And that, my friends, is a fact.

Also, when he was fighting his nephew Jacen became Darth Caedus, he easily defeated him......and Caedus considered himself to be the greatest duelist of his time. Nice point Jax very nice.


Alucardsig2-1.jpg



Revan_Malak

Dread Lord

50 XP

4th August 2008

0 Uploads

339 Posts

0 Threads

#6 10 years ago

You guys are crazy!4-1 Luke?You seriously need to play through KotOR I one more time.Or II.Doesn't really matter.An interesting fight indeed but Revan never looses a duel unless something gets in the way.




Deus Oblivionis

Domini de Umbra

50 XP

12th August 2008

0 Uploads

871 Posts

0 Threads

#7 10 years ago

Like what Revan_Malak......his cape and robes?


Alucardsig2-1.jpg



JCarter426

I'm watching you...

50 XP

2nd September 2007

0 Uploads

1,503 Posts

0 Threads

#8 10 years ago

It depends on which Luke we're talking about. Well, and which Revan as well, but more importantly Luke. The Luke in the films was a whiny little murglak who barely knew about the existence of the Force, much less how to use it. EU Luke appears to be more worldly and well-rounded, but I've stayed away from most post-ROTJ EU, so I can't really judge.

Therefore, I'm picking Revan out of bias. :p




Guest

I didn't make it!

0 XP

 
#9 10 years ago

Revan of course..... But it will be a hard battle - I mean the Sith'ari vs. the Chosen One !! Plus Revan's teaching were also folowed by a lot of strong Force users - Bastila: battle meditation, The Exile: Killed 3 sith lords - nihilus kreia and sion, Atton the Jedi Killer, Darth Bane Rule of Two,Darth Zannah, Darth Malak, and other Jedi that followed him during the Manda and the J civil War ... tough battle indeed 1!




Revan_Malak

Dread Lord

50 XP

4th August 2008

0 Uploads

339 Posts

0 Threads

#10 10 years ago

Luke Skywalker isn't the chosen one.If you ask me Anakin isn't either.Revan is the one who saved the Republic!Without him there wouldn't be Jedi nor "The Chosen one".Nor Luke for that matter.