Star Trek vs Star Wars???? -1 reply

Please wait...

NCC1701Z

GF makes me horny

50 XP

16th March 2003

0 Uploads

78 Posts

0 Threads

#11 18 years ago

if you go to www.ditl,org, you can see the 6 chapter story of star trek vs star wars. and if you look a close look at weaponry, you can see that lasers are deflected by the primary nav. deflector. and the Q.... picard and especially (Q's best friend, i presume?) could make an alliance and one tic!! all the imperial star destroyers are gone! end of debate~~:rock: :rock: :dance:




borg121

I am a modder in need of help

50 XP

27th December 2002

0 Uploads

680 Posts

0 Threads

#12 18 years ago
Cpt Geddes

SWFC: AP modeller

50 XP

1st September 2002

0 Uploads

173 Posts

0 Threads

#13 18 years ago

Yuuzhan Vong????

Who are they. I haven't heard of them before.

Star wars has more numbers than any star trek race (most of the galaxy is "owned" by the New Republic. What about a SSD? What about a cube?

Hyperdrive means that star wars ships can get to a battle quicker to reinforce areas. Surely when one side captures the other sides ship they will understand more about that race and their technology so they will be able to "adapt" to defeat them. Those sun crushers could be mass produced and could ram any ship to destroy it. Cloaking devices would be a great advantage as star trek cloaks are better. I don't think star wars ships will be able to detect a star trek cloak. Jedi. Sith. They would be able to infiltrate a star trek ship and slaughter everyone (I say slaughter as it would be easy because star trek races wouldn't know how to defend themselves).

Everyone is talking about space ships. What about destroying a ship from the inside? Or ground assaults? Those AT-AT's will put up a good fight against whatever ground vehicles star trek has.

I personally think star wars would lose after a long, long, long collosle war. The Borg and Dominion would come out better than all other races as they have the ability and numbers to destroy any invading race. The Borg haven't assimilated the Alpha quadrent as they are too arrogant and continue to under estimate other species. The Dominion didn't get a chance to show their true power as their 1000's of ships were destroyed by the prophets in the wormhole and they had the 4 major races of the Alpha quadrent against them!

Anyway I'm side tracking, it would be a war that would leave all sides in ruins and not much left.




Admiral Pellaeon

Grand Admiral

50 XP

21st January 2003

0 Uploads

16 Posts

0 Threads

#14 18 years ago

The Yuuzhan Vong are a race that has invaded the galaxy that Star Wars takes place in. They HATE machines, so they use biotech. Everything they use is alive including their hand to hand weapons, armor, and their star/warships. Instead of building things they grow it. They even destroyed a planet and used the remains as a shipyard. Anyway, they are very hard to kill even by Jedi cuz their armor and hand to hand weapons deflect lasers and lightsabers both.

The Yuuzhan Vong ships use plasma and some type of molten rock weapons. Being they don't use LASERS the stupid comment about the lasers being deflected by the primary nav. deflector (ya right) won't apply to them.

The Yuuzhan shields are actually little black wholes, produced by the same creatures that move their ships. The creatures can also rip the shields of ships and suck in things that get to close.

Ya, the Jedi could also detect cloaked ships and the dark Jedi(I don't think the Jedi would aprove of them doing this) could control the crew on the emeny ships.

Star Wars also has Centerpoint Station that can shoot through hyperspace and with someone like Anakin Solo (to bad he's dead) could destroy whole fleets (Those Borg cubes would make nice big targets, it might be hard to miss them).

Considering the Q think that humanity is a threat I really don't think they would do anything but sit back and watch. I also don't think we are even talking about the Q having any part of the conflict. It's about the people, their societies, and their weapons if it was otherwise ( like including Q-like beings) then it was pointless to start this thread.




Guest

I didn't make it!

0 XP

 
#15 18 years ago

o yea-another debate. the one at bcfiles hit 22 really long pages.' Theres a lot of good info there too.




Guest

I didn't make it!

0 XP

 
#16 18 years ago

Aren't the Uzen Vong peeps part of the EU.




Admiral Pellaeon

Grand Admiral

50 XP

21st January 2003

0 Uploads

16 Posts

0 Threads

#17 18 years ago

Yep, they are.




Guest

I didn't make it!

0 XP

 
#18 18 years ago

---"Recently, Lucas cleared up the messy issue by explaining that the books, games, and comic books are part of a parallel universe, another world created separately from his own (Lucas in Cinescape). By design, the settings in time of the parallel universe do not intrude on his movie time period, since LucasBooks disallows authors from playing with events and periods of time that Lucas intends to use."--- http://www.gamingforums.com/showthread.php?threadid=12204&perpage=40&pagenumber=19 non canon-i think we determined




tyrkina

GF Pwns Me!

50 XP

18th March 2003

0 Uploads

56 Posts

0 Threads

#19 18 years ago

:naughty: im gonna just add my input to this hope i dont get flamed too badly

1 lucas arts had originaly authorised all of the books rpg games made by other companies as per there agreement to use the name. the idea he now claims as they are 2 separate universas is because the clown fudged up leting other people write stuff for him and he didnt check them enough as they apparently mess with his plans.

2 sun crushes cant be mass produced as there armour is so rare they used all of it to make the first one. (i might be wrong on this one)

3 you cannot accuratly compare the 2 game systems as there are similar but vastly different.

4 If you do decide to compare them then you have to understand this. the emporer had over 2000 fleets hidden throughout space waiting for his aproval for the ships to return for crewing and assingment. the largest ships messured miles in lenght and a mile in width( i do not remember the class of this ship)all ships in star wars used missils they didnt in the movies much but there scematics have them; the only way and i mean the only way star wars could win aginst star treck is the act of MASSIVE FORMATIONS AND FIRE POWER.

That being said and done i thank you for not flaming me too bad(i hope) And the only reason i stated any of this is a i have all the books for star wars includeing its rpg game and love star treck as much as Star Wars:uhoh: :cya: :rock: :fistpunch:




Guest

I didn't make it!

0 XP

 
#20 18 years ago

http://www.gamingforums.com/showthread.php?postid=496139#post496139

Add any of ur arguments, just might want to read the whole thread. (I read the entire thing since the start and it is L-o-n-g