Take your time. It's better to take longer and achieve better results.
Imo the barrel is too short (This is the original model from DMC4) It looks good, but ingame it'll look like a regular revolver with two barrels. Nero's gun was HUGE...
looks generally the same to me.
I agree. About the same.
Well, a very minor nitpick: in your design, the indentations on the cylinder seem to be placed right above the chambers.
It still looks too short to me... But whatever.
I believe an in-game picture was shown... followed by a picture of the remade gun...
If anything, it just highlights how well AshuraDX has done in remaking this. The angle of the pictures may distort the size a little - objects in the mirror are closer than they appear.
It looks too short because the whole middle part is wrong and the proportions are off due to that:
The whole loading-cylinder is larger in the original, the hammer is placed and shaped differently, the two "horns" at the end of the barrel are smaller, there are no see through parts and the bit where the trigger is connected to the cylinder is smaller as well. There's more if you look close enough. Still not a bad try, imho.
Other side of the gun (to show the lack of see-through parts):
okay I didnt work much more on it as i was "busy" with playing Assassins Creed here's an small update :