Fitness Bands 7 replies

Please wait...

FileTrekker Über Admin

I'm spending a year dead for tax reasons.

269,299 XP

15th December 2002

85 Uploads

22,518 Posts

1,747 Threads

#1 6 months ago

Does anyone else use them, and how do they find them?

I got a MS Band cause it was really cheap but it has lots of great tech in it. I find the sleep tracking really useful, as I do the other info such as steps, calorie calculating and heart rate monitor.

Does anyone else find when using a heart rate monitor on one of these that it tends to fluctuate a bit like by around 10bpm or so from one minute to the next?


Danny King | Community Manager | GameFront.com



Andron Taps Forum Mod

Faktrl is Best Pony

261,592 XP

10th September 2007

4 Uploads

21,746 Posts

1,754 Threads

#2 6 months ago

Heart rate can change for a multitude of different reasons.  People who don't sleep a lot tend to get higher blood pressure, you may have just finished a cup of coffee, you may have just come up a flight of stairs, or you may just be stressed vs calm from moment to moment at your job.


I'd say though if you're into some kind of regimen, it's a good idea to have a monitor.  Pretty much any increase in exercise or change in diet recommends a visit with your GP so as to make sure you don't kill yourself running 5 miles when there are safer options that help you build yourself up to that point if that's your goal.  As far as calorie counting, you can easily do that with a phone app. There's obviously more to weight control and heart health than just calories.  Carbs get burned before fat and, in starvation mode, muscle gets burned before carbs.  Generally, you want to have a healthy intake of protein to preserve muscle mass while keeping carbs around no more than 50mg per day.  That way, the body starts to power itself through fat cells for energy.  I don't know if most of those devices measure that.

It's...difficult to keep this up on a day-to-day basis when we're constantly busy, and if/when I find a way to make it work I'll let you know tonguez.gif



"I'd shush her zephyr." ~ Zephyr.



FileTrekker Über Admin

I'm spending a year dead for tax reasons.

269,299 XP

15th December 2002

85 Uploads

22,518 Posts

1,747 Threads

#3 6 months ago
Posted by Adrian Ţepeş

Heart rate can change for a multitude of different reasons.  People who don't sleep a lot tend to get higher blood pressure, you may have just finished a cup of coffee, you may have just come up a flight of stairs, or you may just be stressed vs calm from moment to moment at your job.


I'd say though if you're into some kind of regimen, it's a good idea to have a monitor.  Pretty much any increase in exercise or change in diet recommends a visit with your GP so as to make sure you don't kill yourself running 5 miles when there are safer options that help you build yourself up to that point if that's your goal.  As far as calorie counting, you can easily do that with a phone app. There's obviously more to weight control and heart health than just calories.  Carbs get burned before fat and, in starvation mode, muscle gets burned before carbs.  Generally, you want to have a healthy intake of protein to preserve muscle mass while keeping carbs around no more than 50mg per day.  That way, the body starts to power itself through fat cells for energy.  I don't know if most of those devices measure that.

It's...difficult to keep this up on a day-to-day basis when we're constantly busy, and if/when I find a way to make it work I'll let you know tonguez.gif


No but I mean it literally bobs around by around + to - 5bps from moment to moment, not just as and when something happens.

I'll show you;




Danny King | Community Manager | GameFront.com



Mikey Über Admin

Caffiene Fuelled Ravings of an undiagnosed Sociopath.

45,910 XP

13th June 2008

1 Uploads

3,880 Posts

218 Threads

#4 6 months ago

I think it may be because you are looking at it and worrying about it


Mikey - GameFront.com - Lead Developer



FileTrekker Über Admin

I'm spending a year dead for tax reasons.

269,299 XP

15th December 2002

85 Uploads

22,518 Posts

1,747 Threads

#5 6 months ago

I feel calm enough looking at it.

I know that my heart rate there isn't a bad one, it's just I wonder why it fluctuates. The pulsing heart shows the beats and they seem regular enough.


Danny King | Community Manager | GameFront.com



MrFancypants Forum Admin

The Bad

217,011 XP

7th December 2003

0 Uploads

20,003 Posts

6 Threads

#6 6 months ago

Those things are not very accurate, they normally use an indirect measurement (change in skin reflection of light). The mean value is probabably somewhat accurate, but you may see a bunch of weird outliers. The accuracy will probably drop quite a bit when you actually start moving around.




FileTrekker Über Admin

I'm spending a year dead for tax reasons.

269,299 XP

15th December 2002

85 Uploads

22,518 Posts

1,747 Threads

#7 6 months ago
Posted by MrFancypants

Those things are not very accurate, they normally use an indirect measurement (change in skin reflection of light). The mean value is probabably somewhat accurate, but you may see a bunch of weird outliers. The accuracy will probably drop quite a bit when you actually start moving around.

Yeah it seems to be ballpark accurate, good enough for me, it certainly rises and lowers as one would expect, but I guess I shouldn't worry too much about anomolies.


Danny King | Community Manager | GameFront.com



Mikey Über Admin

Caffiene Fuelled Ravings of an undiagnosed Sociopath.

45,910 XP

13th June 2008

1 Uploads

3,880 Posts

218 Threads

#8 6 months ago

I am glad I do not have a heart rate monitor.


Mikey - GameFront.com - Lead Developer