Weekly Poll Results - If you pitted the Defiant against Voyager...

Please wait...

This article originated on the original FileFront

Formatting may be lacking as a result. We apologize for this inconvenience. If this article is un-readable please report it so that we may fix it.

Published by AdmiralHocking 10 years ago , last updated 1 year ago

 

If you pitted the Defiant against Voyager, which would win?

The Defiant would win. 52.8% (138)
pr1.gifpr2.gifpr3.gif
s.gif
Voyager would win the fight. 36% (94)
pb1.gifpb2.gifpb3.gif
s.gif
Neither, the vessels are evenly matched. 9.9% (26)
pb1.gifpb2.gifpb3.gif
s.gif
Other? 1.1% (3)
pb1.gifpb2.gifpb3.gif
s.gif
Total: 261
Start: 07-19-2008 14:58
Last: 07-27-2008 14:32



#1 - Posted by: Stu_1701D (Member) on 07-19-2008 at 16:33

I'd say the Defiant since it was designed to be a warship to use against the Borg and was very effective against the Dominion, but Voyager would give them a though fight... unless Voyager has been refitted with the armor and transphasic torpedoes, then the Defiant is screwed.

#2 - Posted by: Kevinofborg (Member) on 07-19-2008 at 18:16

If you take both ships normally, the defiant would win, but the Endgame voyager would trash the defiant.

#3 - Posted by: RepublicAscendant (Member) on 07-20-2008 at 17:07

for the record, it says "Voyager" not endgame voyager, the defiant would win because it has harder hitting weapons, better armor and quantum torpedoes, not to mention the ship is extreamly manuverable, more so then voyager

#4 - @3 - Posted by: Capt332 (Member) on 07-21-2008 at 16:36

Thank you for pointing that out, i know many people will have voted for Voyager because of the Transphasic Torpoedoes and Armour... The Defiant would win hands down, Photon Torpedoes are nothing compared to Quantum Torpedoes and also the Defiant has 2 layers of protection: Shields and Ablative Armour, where has Voyager has 1: Shields...oh and maybe the makeshift armour created out of coffee beans...

#5 - Posted by: RepublicAscendant (Member) on 07-22-2008 at 04:04

@4: lol coffee bean armor XD

#6 - The Captains... - Posted by: Leftbridge (Member) on 07-22-2008 at 07:31

I think both ships have their ups and downs... but it takes a good captain to out match an opponent... and Captain Sisko would kick some serious Janeway Butt! Hands Down

#7 - Posted by: W4rbird (Member) on 07-22-2008 at 11:20

It depend who would pilot the Defiant....

#8 - Posted by: oberlerchner123 (Member) on 07-22-2008 at 16:17

Try it in Bridge Commander! :p

#9 - Posted by: DDDD4444 (Member) on 07-22-2008 at 21:05

Voyager has a better crew, and more options as a science vessel. it is also equipped with borg technology and alien transporters. Plus they have 7 to modify it into a warship, and the doctor as a holo commando. ;) My bid is on USS Voyager.

#10 - Posted by: adm_tyler (Member) on 07-25-2008 at 09:41

Defiant = Powerful Warship Voyager = Weak joke of a Science Ship Voyager is only designed for exploration and science. Its weapons are not as powerful as other Federation ships, it's Shields would likely not be as powerful either because it was not supposed to fight. Plus, can you see Janeway with the common sense to fire when someone attacks her?

#11 - Posted by: jamesamey (Member) on 07-27-2008 at 02:01

I would say Voyager, admittedly the defiant is more powerful but its firing arcs are extremely bad, it can only fire a decent volley while phasers are forward, so all it would take Voyager as a maneuverable ship would be to get behind them, then they're doomed.

#12 - Posted by: jamesamey (Member) on 07-27-2008 at 02:02

sorry for double post. Plus if worst came to worst, Voyager as the larger ship could ram the defiant

Comments on this Article

There are no comments yet. Be the first!